Top Five Most Overrated Scorers in the NBA

  • PTP Staff

JR Smith and Carmelo Anthony are regarded as two of the most prolific scorers in the NBA, but do they deserve it?


I think it’s safe to say that the NBA has transformed into a game of offense. The days of needing hard nosed defense to be a star in the league have long since passed us, as  flashy moves to the bucket are by far more coveted than the ability to shut down an opposing player.

That has led to an increase of players around the league who are known for their elite scoring abilities, a lot of times deservedly so. Then there are those players who are known as scorers, but their reputation does not match their efficiency. Volume shooters, ball hogs, shot chuckers, these guys can light up the scoreboard, but at the expense of their team’s overall offensive efficiency.

This is not to take away from their abilities as scorers, as everyone on this list does have offensive talent and can be a real weapon when they get hot. But these players often overrated their ability to score, and are heavily responsible for most of their team’s cold streaks due to their need to take every shot possible. Here are the five most overrated scorers in the NBA, an NBA firing squad that should probably leave a few in the clip instead of spraying rounds in hopes of hitting something.

5. Monta Ellis, SG, Dallas Mavericks

At 20 points per game with 16 shots taken per game, Monta Ellis is the definition of a volume shooter. His field goal percentage is at a very respectable .469%, but the fact is he takes too many shots to get to his scoring totals. His shot total is down a bit from past seasons, but the fact remains that he puts the ball up too much to only be scoring 20 points a game.


4. JR Smith, SG, New York Knicks

The only reason JR Smith is not higher on this list is because he is the only non starter.  JR Smith can do one thing, and that is score some points, which is why he has never been a trusted starter in the NBA.

Smith not only was awarded with a nice contract this offseason after scoring a career high 18 points per game, he also was able to get his brother a job in the NBA despite the younger Smith debatably not even being worthy of a D-League roster spot. Smith has thanked the Knicks with a career low .333 field goal percentage and only 11 points scored per game despite seeing the floor over 30 minutes a game.

The electrifying but streaky scorer’s reputation is far exceeding his production, and is continuing to show that his Sixth Man of the Year season may have been more of a flash in the pan than a step forward in the story of JR Smith.


3. Brandon Jennings, PG, Detroit Pistons

The best way to describe Brandon Jennings would be an enigma. The streaky pseudo star has gone on tears that have single handedly led his teams to major victories, followed by cold nights where he looks like a typical schoolyard ball hog.

His streaky shooting has led to a career field goal percentage of .394%, very pedestrian numbers for a point guard averaging a career 17 points per game compared to just six assists a game.  His play has recently picked up in Detroit, but with Jennings it doesn’t seem to be a matter of if, but when his poor shot selection and ball hogging tendencies will come back to haunt him.


2. Rudy Gay, SF, Sacramento Kings

Everywhere Rudy Gay goes, he scores points. That’s a good thing, right? Not so fast. Even though the scorer puts up numbers when he is the focal point of the offense, every team he has left has been just as good on offense without him, perhaps even better. From the up and coming Memphis Grizzlies to the now surging Raptors, no team he’s been on seems to miss Gay’s scoring abilities.

While Gay’s talents as a scorer are undeniable, the offensive success teams have had without him is also undeniable. Gay is considered a star by many in the NBA primarily for his scoring abilities, and that label may be unwarranted given the trend of offensive success by teams he has left.

1. Carmelo Anthony, SF, New York Knicks

I know, I know. Carmelo Anthony is the best scorer in the NBA, a future Hall of Famer, and one of the top three players in the league. That’s fine and dandy. But let me ask you this, would you want a player with a field goal percentage of less than .450% putting up 20 shots a game? That is exactly what Anthony is doing this season, putting up over 20 shots a game and nailing a respectable but unspectacular .447% of them.

Anthony in the past may have been the best scorer in the NBA, but his production this season has left a bit to be desired. People still have him rated up there with Kevin Durants and Lebron James, and I don’t see it. Maybe Melo needs a change of scenery, or maybe he’s just not quite as good as we think he is.


Share & Rate

  • Rate this post

From Around The Web

From SK Network

discussion by

About The Author

PTP Staff

PTP Staff - manager

3 Responses to Top Five Most Overrated Scorers in the NBA

  • Honestly dafuq you on? Carmelo as number 1?!?! This isn’t about defense or passing, THIS IS ABOUT SCORING. Melo is one of the best scorers in the NBA! Who cares if hes taking 20 shots a game! He is the only player who actually CAN score on the Knicks! I completely agree with JR smith being overrated, and he’s part of the reason Melo takes 20+ a game, because no one else will step up to the plate. I couldn’t give a rats ass if someone on my team is taken 20+ a game if your averaging 26 a game. And this is coming from a guy who could care less about Melo.

  • This “article” is the biggest load of shit EVER. I wasn’t too sure of the fact, but once I got to Rudy Gay, I knew it for sure. Just because the Grizzlies are doing well now that he’s gone doesn’t mean a damn thing; it simply means that they can find other players who can score. Oh, and by the way, who did they get to replace him as their SF? Tayshaun Prince? Last time I checked, he’s averaging less than a third of what Rudy Gay averages now AND when he was in Memphis. As far as Carmelo goes, his case is self-explanatory. Right now, only four people are averaging double-digit PPG and one of them ISN’T Amar’e Stoudemire. Who did you want to be the top scorer for the Knicks, Andrea Bargnani? Ain’t a damn thing overrated about Carmelo man. Fuck outta here…

    • Jason Whitney

      I didn’t write the article, but you failed to address why the Raptors are now better without Rudy Gay? And you are in the minority when it comes to backing Gay as stat analytic geeks have crushed him for years as not being an efficient player. But tossing out a bunch of “f-bombs” and Tayshaun Prince isn’t going to change many minds. Prince also isn’t taking as many shots as Gay did. That trade was made because of Gay’s salary, but refresh my memory, how far did the Grizzlies get without Gay last year?

Leave a Comment

Fill Out All Required Fields

8 − = 4

From SK Network