Ten current MLB players who should be first ballot Hall of Famers

  • David Whitlock
Prev1 of 12Next
Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse

Voting criteria scrutiny seems increased for the National Baseball Hall of Fame these days, with the unprecedented question of players suspected of using performance enhancing drugs (PEDs) figuring in the discussion.  Despite that, here are ten current MLB players (as of 2014) who should be first ballot Hall of Famers.  Maybe not all first ballot by the time the votes are tallied due to ballot traffic and some voters excluding worthy numbers on the first ballot appearance to make a point, but there is a strong case presented (including a Hall of Fame “comp” for each).  For the purposes of this list, any player actually suspended for use of PEDs is excluded (Alex Rodriguez, Ryan Braun to name a couple).  Just being suspected is not enough to keep you off this list.  A minimum of five (elite) years in the league is required, so we’re not speculating about guys like Yasiel Puig or even Mike Trout who have so much career in front of them.  We’ll present in reverse order, starting with the least certain and ending with sure-fire first ballot.  Stats are as of article publication (August 2, 2014)

Credit: National Baseball Hall of Fame

Credit: National Baseball Hall of Fame

Prev1 of 12Next
Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse

Share & Rate

From The Web

From SK Network

discussion by

About The Author

David Whitlock

David Whitlock - manager

David (a.k.a. Longhorndave or lhd_on_sports) joined the staff late in the 2012 season and moved to Site Manager in early 2013. A lifelong Houston Astros fan (and mini-season ticket holder for 9 years) he attends 20+ games per year. A statistics freak, David still keeps score the "old fashioned way" on occasion (and has kept manual score of World Series games since 1986 and retains the sheets). He was a featured guest weekly on the Phil Naessens Show. He is also a Texas Longhorns alumnus and huge football and baseball fan of his alma mater. When he isn't watching or writing about baseball, he works as a contractor at NASA Johnson Space Center. He lives by the mantra "a bad day at the ballpark is better than a good day anywhere else."

14 Responses to Ten current MLB players who should be first ballot Hall of Famers

  • No to Ortiz, he was mentioned in the Mitchell report, and there is no doublt he was, and still is on the juice. Video game numbers are proof.

    • he wasn’t mentioned in the Mitchell report. In fact, Yankee fans use the fact that Mitchell is a Boston fan and had no Redsox on the list to discredit it. Ortiz name was called out the same time Manny was called out. Months after the Mitchell report

    • He was not in the Mitchell report. Yankee fans use the fact Mitchell is a Boston fan and no Redsox was included in the Mitchell report. Ortiz was called out because him and Manny failed the anonymous drug test in ’03. Since it was anonymous, Ortiz and his fans claim it didn’t count so he didn’t get caught

  • “Rumors” of PED use? Regardless of it taking place before penalties, failed test = “guilty of PED use”.

  • I would add Mauer to the list.

  • What about CC Sabathia?

  • Jimmy Rollins? The numbers just are not there, they mention that his numbers are better than Ozzie Smith. I never thought he should be in the HOF either. Ozzie got in based on his popularity and defense but his offensive numbers were anemic. I just can’t see players making it on defense alone.

  • As far as Ortiz is concerned, he apparently failed a PED test as noted in the Mitchell report but hasn’t been mentioned since. I don’t know how easy it is to avoid positive results, if he’s still using he’s done a great job of hiding it.

  • A couple of guys mentioned still have a long way to go before establishing HOF credentials. Clayton Kershaw and Felix Hernandez need to keep up their numbers over a longer period of time. They are certainly on track but if their careers ended today they wouldn’t and shouldn’t make it.

  • Jeter is someone who some people claim is overrated. Look at those numbers, I don’t know what justifies those comments. Compare him to Ozzie Smith who I mentioned earlier. Jeter has 12 seasons batting over .300, Ozzie one. He has 259 home runs, Ozzie 28, 1281 RBI, Ozzie 793. I could go on but you get the point.

  • Ortiz was in Mitchell report. If he gets in, so should the rest.

Leave a Comment

Fill Out All Required Fields


3 + 8 =

From SK Network